Does IMAX need to be minimized?

By Ryan Denkovic

Recently, the trend of utilizing IMAX cameras during production has taken the American film industry by storm, with films like “Dune: Part Three” and “Digger” dedicating a large part of their marketing that segments of the picture were “filmed for IMAX.” It  has even ventured outside the States with “Godzilla Minus Zero,” the first Japanese movie that was filmed for IMAX, releasing in November. While I think that it is a cool way to see a movie in concept, it is becoming less of a tool and more of a crutch. 

“IMAX” refers to a system of cameras and theaters that shoot or display a different aspect ratio than that of a normal theater; and IMAX theaters are known for having extremely large screens and seating, similar to that of a football stadium. The average cinema screen has a ratio of 2.39:1, whereas IMAX screens have a ratio of either 1.9:1 or 1.43:1, depending on certain theaters. Combine that with the screen size, and you get a spectacle of a viewing experience. Now, if this is where it ended, I would have no  problem with it, but so many films recently are using this gimmick in a way that alienates people who do not see a film in IMAX; and the biggest perpetrator of this has to be Christopher Nolan.

A new film format is becoming more of a gimmick than a gift.
Graphic by Nick Medal.

Nolan is known for a few things: his use of time in his films, his inability to write female characters and his use of IMAX in his films. Nolan’s “The Dark Knight” was the first major film to use IMAX cameras, and he has used IMAX in most — if not all — of his movies since. His most recent film “The Odyssey,” however, was shot entirely on IMAX, and this was a huge selling point during its marketing.                                     

Many critics and audiences who were shown early screenings of the film emphasized the importance of seeing the film in IMAX 70 mm, which uses a 1.43:1 aspect ratio. This creates a problem, as not watching the film in IMAX 70 mm means you are losing a whopping 40% of the actual image. As an artist, this pains me because, as much as I love respecting another artist’s creative vision, I think that losing nearly half of a film’s image is not fair to those who cannot see the film in that format; and I am worried that, given the critical and financial success of the most overhyped film this year, this could start to become a problem in the future with other films. Some have proposed that for “The Odyssey,” they could have released it in theaters with letterboxing on the sides so that those seeing it in a normal format would be able to see the full picture. Lance Oppenheim’s “Primetime” did something similar, having been shot almost entirely in a 1.50:1 ratio and it worked beautifully. 

Admittedly, I have not seen a film in IMAX yet, so maybe I am wrong and it is everything it is cracked up to be. Until then, I am going to stand with my opinion that IMAX is keeping the full vision of filmmakers’ artistry from people who do not have the proximity or finances to go see this format in the theater.

Ryan Denkovic is a sophomore English major

The Rider News

The Rider News gives any student or member of the community the opportunity to write and submit their work to… More »

Related Articles

Back to top button